The Real Reason You Can’t Stick to New Habits (and How to Fix It After 40)

You start strong every Monday — new routine, new promises, new motivation. By Thursday, you’re tired, behind, and telling yourself you’ll start again next week.

Sound familiar?

A few of my favourite books

If you’ve ever felt frustrated wondering why you can’t seem to stay consistent, you’re not alone — and it’s not because you’re lazy or undisciplined.

After 40, life looks different. You’re managing more responsibilities, your energy shifts, and your body and brain don’t respond the same way they used to. The habits that worked in your 20s or 30s often just don’t fit anymore.

The real problem? You’re trying to stay consistent with systems that no longer serve the woman you are today.

Let’s fix that.

Step 1: Redefine What Consistency Really Means

Consistency isn’t doing it every single day. It’s doing it more often than not.

It’s showing up — even when it’s messy, short, or imperfect.

Once you drop the all-or-nothing mindset, you make space for real momentum.

A 10-minute walk counts.

A protein-rich breakfast counts.

Journaling for 3 minutes counts.

Because small wins done often beat the perfect plan done once.

Try this: Set a minimum baseline — the smallest version of your habit that still moves you forward.

• “I’ll move for 10 minutes.”

• “I’ll prep one protein and one veggie.”

The goal isn’t perfection — it’s to rebuild trust with yourself, one small promise at a time.

Step 2: Anchor New Habits to the Ones You Already Have

After 40, you don’t need a full lifestyle overhaul — you need integration.

You already run on autopilot habits: your morning coffee, the drive to work, your evening scroll. Stack your new habits onto those.

This is called habit stacking, and it’s one of the easiest ways to make new behaviors automatic.

Try this:

• After I brew my morning coffee → I’ll drink a glass of water.

• After I eat breakfast → I'll take out protein for dinner.

• After I brush my teeth → I’ll stretch for 2 minutes.

• After I close my laptop → I’ll write tomorrow’s top 3 priorities.

Small, anchored actions lead to effortless consistency.

Step 3: Align Habits With Your Season of Life

The routines that worked at 25 won’t necessarily serve you at 45 — and that’s a good thing.

Your hormones, stress, energy, and recovery all play a role now.

Ask yourself:

What do I need more of right now — calm, strength, focus, or energy?

What habits actually support that need?

If you’re constantly exhausted, maybe it’s not another workout you need — it’s better recovery and nutrition. If stress runs high, a 5-minute breathing routine might do more for you than a new diet plan.

The most sustainable habits are built for your real life, not an ideal one.

Step 4: Design an Environment That Makes Success Easier

Willpower fades. Environment wins.

If your gym clothes are buried under laundry or your snacks are all ultra-processed, you’re making consistency harder than it needs to be.

Try this:

• Lay out your workout clothes the night before.

• Keep a water bottle on your desk.

• Make the healthy choice the visible one.

Your environment should support your goals — not sabotage them.

Step 5: Track Progress Without Obsessing

Tracking isn’t about perfection — it’s about awareness.

When you see patterns, you can adjust before you spiral.

Try this: Use a simple tracker, notebook, or app to note how often you follow through each week.

At the end of the week, reflect:

• What helped me stay consistent?

• Where did I fall off — and why?

It’s not judgment — it’s data. Everything is data - and data leads to better decisions.

Step 6: Focus on Identity, Not Outcome

The goal isn’t to “lose weight” or “work out more.” It’s to become the kind of woman who takes care of herself.

You’re not “trying to eat healthy.” You’re a woman who nourishes her body.

You’re not “forcing yourself to work out.” You’re a woman who moves because she values her strength.

When your actions match your identity, consistency becomes effortless.

Step 7: Build Grace Into Your Routine

You’ll have off days. You’ll miss workouts. Life will interrupt you.

That doesn’t mean you failed — it means you’re human.

Don’t start over. Just start again. There’s a big difference.

Step 8: Stop Living the “Week vs. Weekend” Life

One of the biggest consistency killers is living in cycles of “be good during the week, unwind on the weekend, start over Monday.”

That stop-start rhythm keeps you stuck.

When you treat every day as a chance to feel your best — not just the weekdays — you break free from that pattern.

Try this: Keep one or two anchor habits that never change — even on weekends. Maybe it’s your morning walk or your protein breakfast.

You can have joy and discipline. You can relax and stay aligned. Balance doesn’t come from restriction — it comes from intention.

Final Thoughts

The reason most women over 40 can’t stick to habits isn’t lack of motivation — it’s lack of alignment. When you start small, work with your season of life, and focus on identity over outcome, everything shifts.

You stop chasing consistency… and start living it.

Because the goal isn’t to be perfect — it’s to become the kind of woman who always comes back to herself.

Xo, LB